< Back to Dr. John Smetanka's Blog

Lessons from The Hunger Games

By: Dr. John Smetanka
Posted Wed., March 21, 2012

hunger gamesSuzanne Collins creates a classic dystopian future in The Hunger Games on par with Huxley’s Brave New World, Orwell’s 1984 and Vonnegut’s Fahrenheit 451. The movie adaption of the book will be released this week. Collins adds an especially horrifying twist to an otherwise familiar vision of a tyrannical central government that oppresses the majority of its citizens who labor to produce the goods but prohibited from sharing in the overall prosperity. That twist is the law that each year 24 adolescent “tributes” are selected to participate in a fight to the death choreographed for television called the Hunger Games. The Hunger Games themselves are reminiscent of the combat of gladiators in ancient Rome combined with the spectacle of a 21st century Olympic Games complete with human interest interviews and personal stylists for each competitor. As with most of the governments in this genre of novels, the rule of law is corrupted to benefit an elite class and to keep the majority (the producers) enslaved.

Of course human history is ripe with examples of governments falling into tyranny. Whether one chooses to study Rome under the Caesars, France under Napoleon, Stalin’s Soviet Union, Hitler’s Nazi Germany, or Mao’s China, we see a similar imposition of laws that limit personal liberty for the so called public good. The more restrictive the rules of law, the fewer individual liberties remain for the general citizen, and the deeper a government spirals into tyranny.

The fact that each generation produces one or more novels that teaches this valuable lesson is not surprising. The fact that tyrannies continue to exist despite these repeated warnings tells us something about the human condition. We must be watchful to recognize when laws become too restrictive and when common sense is usurped by rules and regulations.

Aristotle called the greatest virtue “practical wisdom.” This was the gift that Solomon prayed for and received from God. It is the gift of discerning the right way to do the right thing. The book Practical Wisdom authored by two Swarthmore College faculty, Barry Schwartz, the Dorwin Cartwright Professor of Social Theory and Social Action, and Kenneth Sharpe, Professor of Political Science, highlight the need for a human approach to the problems facing our institutions – government, education, and health care. With carefully chosen examples they illustrate heartwarming cases in which decisions are rendered specific to the unique circumstances of a given problem and heart-wrenching cases in which blindly following laws, guidelines or scripts leads to folly. Professor Schwartz’s talk “Using Our Practical Wisdom“ conveys a few of these stories (http://www.ted.com/talks/barry_schwartz_using_our_practical_wisdom.html).

Whether we are talking about establishing rules and regulations to improve education, provide better health care, or make government more efficient we must remember that no sets of rules can replace the human application of practical wisdom. It is why our justice system relies on judges, lawyers, and juries and not just law books and sentencing guidelines. It is why our medical system relies on doctors and nurses and not just expert systems. And it is why our educational system relies on teachers and not actors following a script. What are needed are leaders of good character and virtue. Today, as it was in the times of both Aristotle and Solomon, the path to practical wisdom is a solid and broad education tempered with careful observations of day to day experiences.
 

Comments:

Dr. Smetanka, I enjoyed your take on "The Hunger Games." However, there is an error in the first sentence of this piece: Ray Bradbury (not Kurt Vonnegut) wrote "Fahrenheit 451." Best, Ryan Hrobak
Posted by: Ryan Hrobak at May 4, 2012 3:15pm
You have put great unique views in this content. I agree with many of your primary points. This information is clearly written for readers that enjoy very challenging content. This is perfect for us thinkers.
Posted by: holis at June 28, 2012 3:01am
Intresting read.If anyone likes ps1 games check this site out http://psxisorom.blogspot.gr/
Posted by: Adrian at September 14, 2012 8:02am
That was a good read. I will be back. Thanks http://www.usedipad123.com
Posted by: iPad cases at November 9, 2012 4:29pm

Comment on this:

Post Comment

Blog Author

john_smetanka_thumb

Dr. John Smetanka,
Academic Affairs

Dr. John J. Smetanka has been a member of the full-time faculty since 1997 and currently serves as the Vice President for Academic Affairs and Academic Dean of Saint Vincent College, a position he has held since January, 2008.