NAIA All-American

2003, 2006

Consuegra, a freshman second baseman, finished third in the conference with a .417 batting average. He was second on the team with 41 RBI.

He earned a second All-America nod his senior year, playing behind the plate, batting .412 and becoming the school's all-time leader in hits. 

NAIA All-American

2004

Pichler, a senior third baseman, was named Player of the Year in the American Mideast Conference North Division. He batted .359 and led the team in home runs (8) and RBI (41).

NAIA All-American

2004

Brogan, a sophomore right-hander, was a perfect 7-0 for the season. He struck out 54 batters in 59.1 innings, including a season-high 12 against Malone College.

NAIA All-American

2004

Hermann, a senior catcher, batted .359 for the year, with 11 doubles and two home runs. Defensively, he threw out 21 baserunners.

NAIA All-American

2003

Watkins, a sophomore, set modern-day school records with a 2.61 season ERA and 65.2 innings pitched. He had a record of 8-2, which was the second highest single-season win total in school history.

NAIA All-American

2002

Morgan, a senior, batted .449 for the year, a modern record for Bearcat baseball. He hit seven doubles and five triples among his team-high 53 hits.

NAIA All-American

2001

DeAugustine, a catcher, earned All-America honors as a sophomore in 2001 thanks to a stellar year both behind and at the plate. He threw out 26 of 30 runners, while batting .392 and leading the team with 34 RBI.