| Date | Opponent | Site | Record | Score | | | Notre Dame College (MD) | H | 0-1 | L, 15-16 | | | Lees McRae (NC) | H | 0-2 | L, 11-13 | | | Shenandoah | A | 1-2 | W, 12-6 | | | Indiana University of PA | A | 1-3 | L, 5-11 | | | Wittenburg | H | 2-3 | W, 13-8 | | | Allegheny College (PA) | H | 3-3 | W, 16-12 | | | Ohio Wesleyan College (OH) | A | 3-4 | L, 12-13 | | | Kenyon College (OH) | A | 3-5 | L, 9-10 | | | Hood College (MD) | A | 4-5 | W, 20-9 | | | Mercyhurst College (PA) | H | 5-5 | W, 11-7 | | | Wooster College (OH) | H | 5-6 | L, 7-17 | | | Gannon University (PA) | A | 5-7 | L, 3-20 | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|